EOS Developer Acknowledges Claims of ‘Collusion’ and ‘Mutual Voting’ Between Nodes

EOS acknowledges accusations of voting manipulation and pay-offs after claims that important EOS nodes are taking part in “mutual voting.”

Block.one, the developer of blockchain protocol EOS, has revealed a press release on EOS public blockchain governance in an official Medium submit October 1, signed by Block.one’s CEO, Brendan Blumer.

In the assertion, Blumer states that the corporate is “conscious of some unverified claims relating to irregular block producer voting, and the following denials of these claims.”

Without offering any particulars on the “denials” of allegations, Blumer acknowledged that EOS will proceed to “guarantee a free and democratic election course of and […] vote with different holders to strengthen the integrity of this course of.”

The assertion follows current allegations that accuse the platform’s main Block Producers (BPs) — the equal of miners on the Bitcoin (BTC) blockchain — together with Chinese crypto change Huobi, of “mutual voting” and “collusion.”

The accusations started to floor final week, when Eosone, which had already revealed a report on controversial EOS BPs this September, posted what it claims was a leaked Huobi spreadsheet in its weblog on WeChat. The spreadsheet contained 4 tables with “node mutual voting table” and “node income statement” amongst them.

As per Eosone, this might imply that important EOS nodes, together with Chinese crypto change Huobi (the fourth BP in present producer rating, in accordance with EOS Titan), had been concerned in mutual voting together with pay-offs.

The top 21 BPs in current EOS ranking, according to EOS Titan. Source: EOS Titan

The high 21 BPs in present EOS rating, in accordance with EOS Titan. Source: EOS Titan

Twitter consumer Maple Leaf Capital offered an in depth clarification of the inner doc in English. Per the tweet, Huobi voted for 20 different BPs, and 16 of them voted again for Huobi.

A list of EOS BPs allegedly involved in mutual voting. Source: @MapleLeafCap

An inventory of EOS BPs allegedly concerned in mutual voting. Source: @MapleLeafCap

Per the above desk, Huobi voted for 3 different BPs in change for vital pay-offs. Maple Leaf additional explains the info from the spreadsheet:

“Huobi votes for eosiosg11111, cochainworld, and eospaceioeos in change for 170, 150, and 50% of the returns respectively…”

Maple Leaf additional wrote that such trade-offs may “increasingly compromise the integrity of the network,” notably on condition that not less than 12 of 21 main BPs had been managed by Chinese entities.

The Twitter consumer additional linked the alleged mutual voting with the current promotion of Huobi Pool Token (HPT,) which shared tokens with customers in change for locking their EOS on Huobi. The Chinese crypto change would possibly then use these votes at their discretion, Maple Leaf concluded.

All listed allegations, if confirmed, may battle with Article IV of the present EOS Constitution referred to as “No Vote Buying”, which states the next:

“No Member shall supply nor settle for something of worth in change for a vote of any sort, nor shall any Member unduly affect the vote of one other.”

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin commented in regards to the thread began by Maple Leaf Capital, saying the vote-trading was “utterly predictable”:

“Interesting! I imply, it was utterly predictable and I did predict it,  however I didn’t anticipate it to occur so totally and so quickly!”

Buterin additionally criticized the very system of EOS nodes:

“As a followup, *this* is why I don’t consider in coinholder-voted on-chain treasuries. Any chain the place coinholder-voted on-chain issuance is used to supposedly fund public items can simply collapse into this sort of ‘I vote in your crappy challenge, you vote for mine’ equilibrium.”

Original supply: https://cointelegraph.com/news/eos-developer-acknowledges-claims-of-collusion-and-mutual-voting-between-nodes

The post EOS Developer Acknowledges Claims of ‘Collusion’ and ‘Mutual Voting’ Between Nodes appeared first on Bitcoin Upload.


Source: BTC Upload